Saturday, November 24, 2018

The Outsiders - Janis and Taylor - Defiant to the End

In English 61, Mr. Lewenstein asked us to compare our sixties subject to something or someone more familiar from today's age.  He told us the deeper we went into our comparison, the better we would understand our topic.  When I first thought of it, I couldn't think of anyone more different than Janis Joplin and Taylor Swift.  Their looks, their styles, their attitudes are opposite extremes.  But the more I read, the closer they became.  They are both ambitious in their love and their music.  They are two of a kind.


As young girls, both Janis and Taylor found themselves socially on the outside looking in, but that’s probably what pushed them both to songwriting.   They didn’t really fit into their high-school crowd.  They weren’t really followers.  They were free-spirits.  They were dreamers. 
Janis grew up in an affluent family in Port Arthur, Texas, but she ran away at age 17 because she felt like such an outcast.    While her high-school classmates were listening to Top 40 coming out of the AM radio, Janis was crazy for black blues legends like Bessie Smith, Big Mama Thorton, and Leadbelly.   In 1963, she landed in the psychedelic, drug-energized San Francisco music scene where she established her own unique sound as white blues queen and rock ‘n’roll mama. Janis  once said, "Aretha Franklin, Billie Holiday....They are so subtle, they can milk you with two notes. They can go no farther than from A to B, and they can make you feel like they told you the whole universe.”  

While Janis sought inspiration from the blues, Taylor’s songs often come straight out of her personal experience.  She writes about her her feelings, her dreams, and her heartbreaks.  Beginning  in middle school and continuing through high-school, Taylor didn’t have many friends or people to talk to.  She felt like an outsider looking in.  But all that misery and rejection pushed her towards songwriting.   She spilled her guts on paper.  Writing songs was like keeping a diary.  According to Taylor, she tries to write songs that people her age could relate to.  When she writes,  Taylor says she writes in real time.   She strives to be personal and honest..  In her songs, she shares the sadness and letdowns of her own relationships because she wants to let her fans know they are not alone: “Nobody ever lets me in/ I can still see you, this ain’t the best view/  On the outside looking in.” (from a song she wrote when she was twelve: “The Outside.”) 


 I read that both Janis and Taylor were often teased and bullied in high school. It’s like whatever makes you different at that age makes you somehow uncool.  At a certain point, they must have thought there was no chance to be part of the crowd.  I can only imagine their insecurities.  

Fortunately for them, music became their own form of therapy.  They may have not had anyone to talk to, but they were only a guitar away from saying something special.   Their music tells us it’s okay to stand apart.

Janis and Taylor - Compare and Contrast - The Runaways


In English 61, I'm writing my sixties research paper on Janis Joplin.  You can consider her a rock 'n' roll pioneer.  She was one of the first women performers to take center stage in the decade of the sixties.  You can say she paved the way for women rockers to follow - one of them, of course, being Taylor Swift.  Here, I compare their musical beginnings.

As soon as they possibly could, both Janis and Taylor left home to pursue their musical dreams on the big stage.  Janis ran away from home and fled to San Francisco.  Taylor took her family with her south to Nashville, Tennessee to become a star. In 1965, Janis found home in the Haight-Ashbury neighborhood of San Francisco.  This area was known as a mecca for young hippies.  Young people  dressed in bright colors, beads and feathers were coming in from all over the world, and they listened to loud, crazy psychedelic rock.  Janis jammed with the Grateful Dead, Country Joe and the Fish and the Jefferson Airplane.  Her rough and  raucous voice pushed the music to the edge.  “They loved to see her get crazy,” said Joe McDonald of Country Joe and the Fish. “It was part of her image: the wild woman, the blues mama” (Angel 42).  At 14 years of age, Taylor had the talent to earn a songwriting contract with Sony/ATV Records. She was the youngest songwriter they had ever  hired. For Taylor, it was the double life:  during the day, she attended high school like any normal teenager, but at night she was writing songs with professionals two and three times her age. She was right there in the middle of it, that same place – Nashville, Tennessee – that had skyrocketed the careers of music’s biggest stars: Elvis Presley, Patsy Cline, and Dolly Parton. Taylor was especially inspired by the young women that had come through town like Lee Ann Rimes and Shania Twain. Most of all, Taylor explained she loved these stars for  “We don’t care what you think” quirkiness (Spencer 16). While most teens spend their high school years finding themselves, both Janis and Taylor were clearly driven by their music.  As soon as they reached a certain age, there would be no waiting and hoping like the rest of us do.  The time for them to move was “now.”
                                    Works Cited 
Angel, Ann.  Janis Joplin: Rise Up Singing. New York: Amulet Books,  2010. Print. 
Spencer, Liv.  Taylor Swift: Everyday is a Fairytale.  Ontario: EECW Press, 2010. Print.



Janis Joplin and Taylor Swift - Freedom through Their Music


As passionate as Janis and Taylor are for their music, it’s no surprise that their lyrics often express their heartbreak for relationships lost.  I mean they are both free spirits. It’s hard to imagine either of them slowing down. How hard that must be to maintain a normal relationship? Their lovers must always feel secondary to their music.  

Janis most famous song – “Me and Bobby McGee” - was actually written by her lover at the time, Kris Kristofferson. It’s a song about discovering the world on your own terms.  There is a line the song about independence that goes like this: “Freedom's just another word for nothin' left to lose. Nothin', don't mean nothin' hon' if it ain't free.”  What brought Janis and Kris together was what drove them apart.   They both wanted to be free, but they would never feel that way in a long-term relationship. 
In the same way, Taylor’s best songs are the most painful.  As much as she dreams of enchanted love, she sings of crushing despair.  In “White Horse,” her lyrics probably approach Janis’s “Me and Bobby McGee” in the way they express the hope to be with a person, and then there is that moment when you know it’s never going to happen.  She sings, “Holding on The days drag on..Stupid girl…I should have known.. I should have known.” Man, all she wanted was the truth. 

When I listen to these songs, I think of one sad disappointment after another.  One’s driving off into the distance.  One dreams of riding off on a white horse.  Whatever are looking for, they’re never going to find it.  The only place to feel free and honest is in their music.



Wednesday, November 14, 2018

The Times They Are A Changin' - Yoli Grows Up Right Before Our Eyes



     Motorcycle on the Sea of Tranquility gives us deep and insightful perpesctive into the Chicano experience.  This story isn’t so much about fighting as it is about loving.       Oquei, Chuy leaves the scene, both physically and emotionally, but in the middle of the night as he terrorizes the whole neighbourhood with his Harley Chopper,  he  seems to wake up a spirit in his little sister. 

Yoli is  almost 15 and  she sees herself as a writer.  Where other girls her age are busy talking about boys and makeup, Yoli has her journal out and is considering the wanderlust spirit she was born with.  She thinks about her father “searching for his El Dorado, a wife and pile of kids in tow.  She thinks about her brother blasting down the highway, and she feels that same  spirit of freedom and wonder tingling between her legs.

     Through Yoli, Santana takes us on a bumpy ride through the Chicano experience of her youth.  And it’s not all that  pretty.  First, and foremost, there is little chance to escape the oppressive role of women in Mexican culture -  Yoli doesn’t even have to leave the house.  Her father dominates her mother and makes the decisions for his daughters.  Her brothers mistreat, abuse and discard some of her closest friends.  Yoli, herself, is hot for a guy named Francisco Valdivia, but if she makes the first move, she knows what she will be labelled as.   How ironic is it that in a time where a man takes his first steps on the moon, the chicana woman is can’t approach a man without being called a puta.

     But with pain, there is growth.   As the legend of Chuy storms toward a violent forboding climax Yoli develops a quiet sense confidence and  independent thought.   What a surprise! In the end, it’s little sister Yoli who steps up to meet the needs of her cowering older brother.  Like  the journey of the moon, Santana’s story comes full circle.  We see at the end of the book that Yoli is ready for her quinceñera.  She is already a woman with secret knowledge and a broken heart.

Real Surprise at the Surprise Party - "Motorcycle" Is Not What You Expect!



      Take a look at the cover to Motorcycle ride on the Sea of Tranquility and amidst the mosaic of bright and happy colors you‘ll catch the blast of a street bike and a young girl’s naked thigh.  What you don´t get is a frightening story that takes place along the mean streets of an East San Diego Barrio. Yoli is 14 and is feeling it -  emotion,  culture and  sex – on the verge of her coming out party.  For Chuy, her favourite brother and returning Vietnam veteran, the party is over.  Patricia Santana paints a picture of a young girl´s innoncence that she will never get back. 

You see, her brother has changed since returning from overseas.  His voice is distant. The gleam in his eye is violent.  The picture is dark and brooding.  Chuy’s soul has  gone up in smoke like the exhaust out of a tailpipe.  

 Santana takes us back to a family reunion cerca April 1969.  A huge pachanga has been planned to celebrate their conquering hero, and  everyone has got their patriotic spirit on.  There`s red, white and blue streamers, frosted sheet cake and Ray Charles on the box. Of course, Yoli´s house is a ten-minute motorcycle ride from Tijuana, so you know there will be  the Mexican colors and plenty of carne asada.  Everyone is singing and dancing and eating.  The Sagahun family has “thrown the house out the window for this one,”   and the only person not digging it, is of course the man of honor, Chuy.  He`s not at all into peace and relaxation.  He’s still a soldier at heart.  He’s not going to give up himself up without a fight.  


He spends his time at the celebration trying to insult and disrespect anything and everything he can.  The world is his piñata.

Motorcycle MVP - "The Look"



Somwhere in the middle of the book, Yoli’s sister tells her not to be a tonta, or not to be a boba. According to Ana Maria, Yoli should just do as she does to make men pay attention.   But its when Yoli comes up with her own “Look”, I think she  establishes herself as her own person.  I vote “The Look” for MVP.


I  can see  how  “The Look” might annoy some readers.    After all, Yoli is clearly smarter and more compassionate than any of the other characters in the novel.   She reads classic literature. She writes poetry in her journal.  And probably most important,  she’s always there first  for her family and friends.  So when we see her strutting down down the locker hall at school all made up like some chola gangster chick, it’s kind of letdown.  I mean, we expect more from Yoli. 
She has enough going on where she doesn’t have to resort to the same old tired stuff that every other girl is trying in that hallway.  Yoli.. where’s the creativity?  The ideas?  Remember,  you are a mad poet!

But , then again Yoli’s new  Look has little to do with  eyelash curler, the mascara or the lipstick that  her sister loaned her.   For Yoli’s sisters and friend, the Look comes from hours spent priming and practicing in front of the mirror, wishing and hoping that their man will notice.   Yoli, however, isn’t the type of person to wait around and let things happen.  She pays more attention  what she feels in her heart than what she sees in the mirror.   Yoli’s Look  came out with her true emotion when she started throwing books in the hallway.   

In the beginning of the novel, Little Yoli learned an important lesson  in the go-kart run from her brother Chuy: he explained to her that real freedom comes when you “ push yourself all the way.”  In this scene with the out-of-control gokart she pushes herself nearly to the point of explosion to experience the feeling.   The same thing happens with Francisco.  When she lets loose with her lethal weapons – her textbooks – sheisn’t thinking about becoming Prom Queen;  she’s Queen of the Javelin throwers, and that feels fine with her.   

“And when the pinches cabrones finally walked past me, silent and embarrassed, not knowing what kind of walk to walk, Francisco’s eyes and mine met, and I gave him The LooK.”
Here, Yoli has stepped out of the shadows of her brothers and sisters.  She is her own person, and she has her own Look.  She’s free at last.  You Go Girl!

Popular Posts